The National Press Photographers Association opposes the New York City Transit proposal to prohibit photography and videotaping in subway and bus systems. Photography, both still and video, is an essential form of speech and a fundamental part of the Constitutional right to freedom of the press and freedom of expression.
The NPPA believes that this proposal is one of an increasing number of efforts that curtail free press and freedom of expression in the name of security.
While media reports indicate that permits could be obtained in advance, we don't believe that this is a solution for several reasons:
Our constitutional rights are an essential part of our society, and we should not allow our enemies to frighten us into curtailing these rights. We do not believe that making allowances for the media would eliminate the chilling effect of this proposed rule.
"Rules like this, while they are designed with the best of intentions are truly ineffective and hinder working photographers everywhere." said NPPA President Todd Stricker. Stricker goes on to explain that the ease and availability of hidden cameras and other methods of observation would make the rule ineffectual against anyone with criminal intentions.
"They'll get their pictures," he said. But in the meantime, legitimate journalists and even members of the public with good intentions will be harmed. "It's one more rule that they can use to harass somebody."
The NPPA calls on the Metropolitan Transit Authority to reject the proposed ban on photography and remove it from the list of rule changes that it is considering.
For more information please contact Todd Stricker, President of the National Press Photographers Association at +1.210.558.7968 or at president@nppa.org
